Best Acoustic Guitar Pickups: What Buyers Need To Know (2024)

Choosing the best acoustic guitar pickup is like finding the perfect coffee blend—essential and personal. After years of tinkering with guitars, I’ve seen how the right pickup can transform your sound.

Imagine strumming your favorite tune and hearing every nuance. That’s what a great pickup does. I’ve tried many, from under-saddle piezos to soundhole models, and each has its charm.

Whether you’re gigging at a local pub or recording at home, I’ll help you find the pickup that matches your vibe. Let’s dive into the world of top rated acoustic guitar pickups and find your sound.

Acoustic Guitar Pickup Types

There is a variety of acoustic pickup types that accommodate all sorts of sounds, performing styles, installation, and budgets. Knowing how one works should further guide you in purchasing the right one for your playing style.

Over the years, I’ve fiddled with various types, each offering its own flavor. Let’s break down the main types you’ll encounter.

Magnetic Pickups

Magnetic pickups (soundhole pickups) are the rockstars of acoustic pickups, quite literally. They work by wrapping insulated copper wire around a magnet, which captures the vibration of your steel strings.

Even though it was first introduced in the early 60s, this type of pickup has never declined in popularity because they are affordable, versatile, doesn’t require any major installation, and can be easily removed.

The benefit of it being placed directly under the strings is that it delivers a clear and detailed sound, with good warmth that’s perfect for flat-picking/strumming.

Its disadvantage is that it can produce a slightly artificial tone, while feedback can also occur especially in the single-coil versions.

Piezo and Transducer Pickups

Now, piezoelectric or piezos, or transducer pickups are the workhorses. They sit snugly between the bridge saddle and the bridge, converting your guitar’s physical vibrations into an electrical signal.

These undersaddle and/or contact pickups are common because they offer a natural sound when amplified. The Piezo-type pickup generally produces bright sound and is an inexpensive option.

Its advantages include a controllable sound with a diminished risk of feedback and the disadvantage is what is known as a “piezo quack” which is a sharp overtone that often accompanies the sound.

Microphone Pickups

If you’re chasing that pure, unadulterated acoustic sound, internal microphone pickups are your best bet. Those small, high-quality microphones that are designed to be mounted inside the body of the guitar produce the best amplified acoustic tones.

Most guitarists generally agree that this type is the best natural way to amplify an acoustic instrument’s tune. However, they can be a bit sensitive to feedback, but they’re fantastic for studio settings or quieter gigs.

Blended / Hybrid Systems

Blended systems combine different pickup types for a balanced sound. Often, they mix piezo and microphone elements.

Imagine having the best of both worlds – the reliability of a piezo and the natural warmth of a mic. I’ve experimented with a few blended systems, and they offer versatility.

Best Acoustic Guitar Pickup Reviews

Here I have put together an extensive buyer’s guide covering six best acoustic guitar pickups that I am positive will walk you through your options and help you make the most suitable choice quickly.

1. L.R. Baggs ANTHEM-SL Acoustic Pickup : Best Overall

Technical Specifications:

• Pickup Type: Hybrid (under-saddle piezo and internal microphone)
• Pickup Position: Under the bridge saddle
• Pickup System: Active
• Available Controls: Volume, mix control
• Built-in Preamp: Yes
• Installation Method: Requires minor modification, battery required (preamp)
• Battery Life: Approx. 170 hours on a single 9V battery

L.R. Baggs Anthem-SL passive type pickup is similar to the regular L.R. Baggs Anthem, except, the Anthem-SL Acoustic Pickup is more minimalist when it comes to the sound controls, comes at a lower price, and generally has a higher rating and better reviews.

It uses TRU MIC technology which mounts to the underside of the bridge plate and its actual sound is almost identical to acoustics recorded in studios. It produces a powerful sound without any low-end feedback.

This L.R. Baggs acoustic pickup is perfect for a wide range of genres and playing styles. Fingerstyle players will appreciate its ability to capture the nuances of fingerpicking, while singer-songwriters will find its natural sound complements their vocals beautifully.

Its balanced tone makes it ideal for folk and Americana musicians, and its feedback resistance is a boon for live performers.

Things I like:

• Low-frequency output
• No feedback problems
• Has a lower price than other pickups with similar features
• Powerful and balanced amplification
• Model available for nylon-string acoustics

Things I don’t like:

• No option for direct tone controls
• Installation requires a professional
• You will need a quick-drain battery for pre-amplification

---

2. Fishman Matrix Infinity VT Acoustic Pickup

Technical Specifications:

• Pickup Type: Under-saddle transducer
• Pickup Position: Bridge
• Pickup System: Active
• Available Controls: Volume, tone shaping, voicing switch
• Built-in Preamp: Yes
• Installation Method: Fits most guitars with string spacings up to 2.5″ (63.5 mm) without modification.
• Battery Life: Approximately 160 hours 

The Fishman Matrix Infinity VT is a top-of-the-line pickup system designed to transform your acoustic guitar into a professional-grade amplified instrument. This active pickup features a narrow format configuration, a built-in preamp, and a versatile tone control.

From the moment you plug it in, you’ll be captivated by the rich, full-bodied tone that this pickup delivers. The sound is nothing short of stunning, with exceptional clarity, warmth, and definition that will elevate your acoustic guitar’s performance to new heights.

Unlike some systems that can sound thin or artificial, this pickup maintains the natural resonance and character of your instrument, ensuring a truly authentic amplified tone.

If you’re after pro-level acoustic amplification, the Fishman Matrix Infinity VT is your ticket to tonal bliss. That’s why it’s no wonder this industry favorite pickup is a go-to for so many musicians.

Things I like:

• Excellent string-to-string balance
• Narrow saddle configuration for seamless integration
• Versatile tone shaping
• Admirable feedback resistance
• Low battery indicator

Things I don’t like:

• Installation may require professional help
• Higher price point than some competitors
• Narrow format may not fit all guitars

---

3. Fishman Neo-D Humbucking Acoustic Pickup

Technical Specifications:

• Pickup Type: Humbucker
• Pickup Position: Soundhole
• Pickup System: Passive
• Available Controls: None
• Built-in Preamp: No
• Number of Sensors: Single neodymium magnet structure
• Installation Method: Easy installation, fits soundholes as small as 3-7/8″ (98.5 mm) in diameter 

The Fishman Neo-D Acoustic Pickup is a game-changer for guitarists seeking crystal-clear sound without breaking the bank. Fishman’s reputation for quality shines through in this pickup.

Its humbucking design is a standout feature, effectively eliminating unwanted noise and feedback. You’ll get a pure, warm tone that truly captures your acoustic guitar’s essence.

The Neo-D boasts a sleek, low-profile design that blends seamlessly with any acoustic guitar. With an easy installation process that doesn’t require modifications to your instrument; you can preserve the integrity of your guitar while upgrading its sound.

The Fishman Neo-D can be a good inexpensive choice for acoustic guitarists seeking a warm, natural sound, as long as a built-in preamp is not a mandatory requirement.

It’s well-suited for folk, acoustic pop, and singer-songwriter genres. Beginners or occasional performers will appreciate its simplicity and reliable performance.

Things I like:

• Delivers natural acoustic tone without coloration
• Simple soundhole pickup design for quick setup
• Passive operation means no batteries required
• Budget-friendly option

Things I don’t like:

• Lacks onboard controls (volume, tone, etc.)
• Not ideal for players who want extensive tone shaping options

---

4. Seymour Duncan SA-3HC Woody HC Acoustic Soundhole Pickup

Technical Specifications:      

• Pickup Type: Magnetic
• Pickup Position: Soundhole
• Pickup System: Passive
• Available Controls: None
• Built-in Preamp: No
• Installation Method: Clip-on, no modification required

Crafted by the renowned pickup manufacturer Seymour Duncan, this hum-canceling pickup offers an excellent solution for guitarists seeking to amplify their instrument without compromising its inherent resonance.

This Seymour Duncan SA-3HC Woody passive magnetic pickup can be directly connected to any guitar (acoustic) that has a sound hole of 3.85 inches to 4.10 inches. With a few position adjustments, more low or high-end punches can be added.

Further, there is enough stabilizer and setting foam to get the positioning that suits you best. The inclusion of a studio-quality 14′ cable further enhances the versatility of the SA-3HC Woody HC, allowing you to easily integrate it into your live or recording setup.

The passive nature of the pickup may require the use of a preamp or DI box to achieve optimal volume and tone, but this is a minor trade-off for the exceptional sound quality it provides.

Whether you’re performing on stage or capturing your guitar sound in the studio, this pickup delivers a consistent and reliable performance.

Things I like:

• Easy mounting
• Solid build and design
• High-quality components
• Produces authentic acoustic sounds
• Hum-canceling design

Things I don’t like:

• Does not mount on nylon-string acoustics
• Volume and tone settings cannot be adjusted
• Finding the best mounting position for maximum sound results is not easy

---

5. K&K Pure Mini Acoustic Guitar Pickup

Technical Specifications:

• Pickup Type: Transducer
• Pickup Position: Bridge plate (inside the guitar body)
• Pickup System: Passive
• Available Controls: None (external preamp recommended)
• Built-in Preamp: No
• Installation Method: No battery required, no modification to the guitar’s bridge or saddle

Renowned for its industry-leading acoustic guitar pickups, K&K has outdone itself with the Pure Mini. Being a passive, pure transducer system, no batteries or other electronic components are needed for operation.

This compact and discreet pickup mounts directly under the guitar’s bridge and it comprises three transducers that pick up two specific strings and capture sounds from around the bridge at the very same time.

Unlike most pickups, K&K Pure Mini Pickup can be mounted to steel and nylon-string acoustic guitars. In my opinion, even after many years since its release, the K&K Pure Mini remains one of the best passive acoustic guitar pickup systems on the market.

Things I like:

• Its system is low-maintenance and easy to use
• Adequate balance and sound clarity
• Limited feedback
• Usable straight out of the box
• Packaging includes a ¼ endpin jack for increased adaptability

Things I don’t like:

• Does not feature direct volume and tone controls
• Does not mount on twelve-string or percussive guitars
• The installation process can be challenging, especially for beginners

---

6. Donner DSS-6 Acoustic Guitar Pickup

Technical Specifications:

• Pickup Type: Magnetic
• Pickup Position: Soundhole
• Active/Passive: Passive
• Available Controls: Volume and tone control
• Built-in Preamp: No
• Materials: Mahogany housing

The Donner DSS-6 Acoustic Guitar Pickup is a fantastic addition to any guitarist’s arsenal. Renowned for its quality sound and affordability, this clip-on pickup is a favorite among musicians.

With its magnetic type pickup, it delivers a warm and authentic sound that seamlessly blends with the guitar’s inherent resonance. The humbucker configuration effectively reduces unwanted noise and hum, providing a clean and consistent output.

Compared to other budget-friendly acoustic pickups, the Donner DSS-6 stands out for its impressive build quality and attention to detail. The mahogany construction not only looks great but also contributes to the pickup’s warm and resonant tone.

The DSS-6 pickup can benefit guitarists across various genres, including folk, country, and blues styles. Its clear and authentic sound makes it suitable for both solo performances and ensemble settings.

Things I like:

• Humbucker configuration reduces noise and hum
• Intuitive volume and tone controls
• Durable mahogany construction
• Easy installation process
• Affordable price point

Things I don’t like:

• Can’t offer the same level of studio-quality recording as more expensive pickups
• Limited customization options compared to higher-end models

---

Factors to Consider When Choosing an Acoustic Guitar Pickup

When choosing the best acoustic guitar pickup system, several factors can significantly impact your sound and performance. Here’s what to keep in mind:

Sound and Tonal Quality

Every guitarist prefers a certain tone, whether you’re playing certain cover songs or you have your original compositions. The right pickup can help you achieve the sound and tone quality you’ve been looking for.

Piezo pickups boost your sound so it tends to produce a brighter tone and more pronounced and clearer sound. Soundhole pickups, on the other hand, depending on quality can sound like your typical electric instrument and can be equalized.

Undersaddle pickups offer a stronger attack and brighter tone but can be a bit thinner.

Convenience and Ease of Use

Gigging musicians need pickups that are easy to install and remove. Piezo pickups are usually clip-on and can be attached to any part of the guitar.

Soundhole pickup can also be a temporary (per-gig) install and easy to remove but can also be permanently drilled into your guitar. Under saddle pickups, on the other hand, may need a pro to install it.

Durability and Performance Endurance

We’re talking about durability, feedback tolerance, and endurance during performances. Of course, sometimes construction quality comes with the price tag of a pickup so you have to consider a few things.

A – is this going to be your main pickup for your main guitar.

B – is this going to be used for recording or performances and how long and often those performances last on average.

C – would this just be a backup pickup in case something goes wrong.

You should choose a pickup that can take the wear and tear of your guitar playing.

Pro Tips for Choosing Best Acoustic Pickup

Combine Different Pickup Types: To achieve the best results, combine different pickup types to leverage their strengths. For example, use an internal microphone pickup to capture the resonance and depth of your guitar’s body, along with a piezo to capture detail.

Mix Magnetic and Microphone Pickups: If the piezo sound is too direct for your taste, combining a magnetic pickup with a microphone can provide a more natural, detailed sound.

Avoid Mixing Piezo and Electromagnetic Pickups: Combining these two types is not recommended as they both mount to the strings, which can cause clashing frequencies and an awkward sound.

In general, blending an internal microphone with another traditional pickup type often yields the best results. If your playing style is more rhythmic, a piezo and internal microphone combination will effectively represent your guitar’s attack.

For a more detail-oriented style, an electromagnetic and microphone combo will capture the nuances of each note.

For more clarity, check out this video guide on how to choose an acoustic pickup:

How to Install a Guitar Pickup for Acoustic?

Acoustic pickups are either permanently or temporarily installed. Some types come as clip-on and are easily installed and removed. Some can have wires, parts, and transducers that need to be permanently fixed on your guitar.

A lot of your guitar’s parts might need to be removed and reattached later on for this, specifically the saddles, bridges, and soundboard. For this, you might require some pro help.

Some clip-on pickups can be attached to a guitar’s body, headstock, and soundhole and would situate much like your electric guitar pickup.

How to Make Guitar Pickups Sound Better?

There are a few modifications that you can do to improve the sound of your pickup. Internally, you may be able to re-wind your pickups.

But what we recommended is to do some external adjustments. For easy-to-attached non-permanent pickups, maybe you can find the right spot on your guitar to put it on.

Use the right strings for your soundhole pickup or make sure the under-saddle pickup was installed properly. Also, you have some guitar effects/enhancers options to choose from.

What Is the Best Way to Amplify an Acoustic Guitar?

The best way to amplify an acoustic guitar depends on the specific needs and preferences of the performer. Here are some of the most effective methods:

1. Microphone: Placing a microphone in front of the acoustic guitar is a straightforward method that can produce high-quality sound. However, it is limited in live performance settings due to the need for close proximity and the potential for feedback.

2. Piezo-Electric Pickup: Piezo-electric pickups, such as those under the bridge saddle, are popular for their high resistance to feedback and affordability. They capture the vibrations of the guitar’s top and require an active circuit with a 9V battery.

3. Magnetic/Soundhole Pickup: Magnetic pickups placed in the soundhole can provide a balanced and articulate amplification of the guitar’s natural sound. They are less prone to feedback and offer a more consistent tone.

4. Preamp/DI Pedal: Using a preamp or direct injection (DI) pedal can provide more control over the sound before it reaches the PA system. This is particularly useful if you have a consistent PA setup or need to shape your sound in a specific way.

5. Acoustic Guitar Amplifier: Dedicated acoustic guitar amplifiers are designed to enhance the tone of electro-acoustic guitars. They often feature EQ sections, built-in effects like reverb and chorus, and can be used with a DI output to connect to a PA system.

6. PA System: Simply plugging into the PA system provided by the venue is the simplest and most cost-effective method. However, it leaves you at the mercy of the venue’s equipment and sound quality.

Each method has its pros and cons, and the best approach depends on the specific needs of the performer, the venue, and the desired sound quality.